Showing posts with label Income Tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Income Tax. Show all posts

Friday, 22 June 2012

Life Is Always Taxing


I don't find Jimmy Carr's version of humour in the least amusing but perhaps that's because I'm of a generation with fond memories of Les Dawson and Morcambe and Wise.

Mr Carr's finances permit him to employ those who specialise in tax avoidance.  Few of us can afford such luxuries and Mr Carr's form of avoidance is not available to those who earn through the PAYE system.

Out taxation system is exceptionally complicated and when laws are excessive there are always loopholes, mainly because over time, one law begins to contradict another. HMRC are well aware of loopholes - they have officers delegated specifically to the issue - but they stand little chance of closing  loopholes because of the lengthy bureaucratic system involved.

I've no problem with anyone managing, legally, to pay less tax - who wouldn't want to do so? What I do have a problem with is Mr Carr's hypocrisy. He's a man who earns his living deriding those who avoid paying standard tax rates yet he is - or was until yesterday - part of that group.

As for his declaration that he has 'made a terrible error of judgement' it smacks of nothing more than a desperate attempt to save his career.

David Cameron's comment about Mr Carr's use of a legal tax avoidance scheme as being 'morally wrong' held a distinct whiff of irony.  Governments legislate on national tax matters but it doesn't suit politicians to push for a fairer, simplified system which would ensure equality for all.  Why would they upset their wealthy friends?

For once Ed Miliband expressed some common sense: "I'm not in favour of tax avoidance obviously, but I don't think it is for politicians to lecture people about morality."

Life is always taxing and in more ways than one as Mr Carr has found out. He obviously doesn't have the same connections as Gary Barlow and Philip Green - both men who have 'interesting' tax arrangements.

Thursday, 9 September 2010

Fact or Fiction?


I promised Thaddeus that I'd support him in his effort to spread the word about this.

James Kirkup isn't known as a hoaxer and there's seldom smoke without fire. For HMRC to claim they're capable of running anything efficiently is certainly humorous but to suggest they may take control of all our earnings, run them through a tax 'calculator', then pass the net salary onto the worker is like something out of an Ed Child's novel.

The tax authorities are consulting accountants, lawyers and businesses on the plans to reform the pay-as-you-earn (PAYE) system. Whoever same up with this idea could make a fortune as an author of fiction.

Saturday, 29 May 2010

Saturday, 16 January 2010

Guest Post by Strathturret




Strathturret has been kind enough to summarise Jim and Margaret Cuthbert's analysis of the Calman Report's financial plans. For those of you who haven't heard of the Cuthberts, they are highly respected Scottish economists.


Jim and Margaret Cuthbert’s critique on Calman’s financial plans.


How Calman's Income Tax Proposals Set a Trap for Scotland


‘We argue here that Calman’s proposals on income tax have serious technical flaws, and pose a grave danger to Scotland.’


I have tried to summarise the Cuthbert’s arguments.



The basic plan is for central government to reduce all income tax rates for all Scots tax payers by 10% points. So you pay 10% rather than 20% if a basic rate tax payer and 30% rather than 40% if a higher rate payer. Westminster reduces Scotland’s block grant by a calculated value equivalent to this 10% tax reduction. The Scots Government then raises additional tax (to replace 10% reduction) and retains this sum collected by these nice people in HMRC.


The Cuthbert’s say that this sounds reasonable at first examination but has two serious flaws.


Effects if Scots Government changes tax rates. Let’s say we decide to reduce tax rate to 8% cf nominal 10%. So a basic tax payer in Scotland pays 18% income tax. Let’s assume that this measure stimulates Scots economy (we all work harder and are more entrepreneurial) and thus the overall Government tax take increases. This could happen as we would have a competitive advantage compared to the rest of the UK. The Cuthberts are concerned that Scotland might get less because the total tax take will be higher but our share could be lower (see example below). So despite stimulating the economy, the Scots Government would take less tax. Perversely, the UK Treasury would benefit from this measure.


Worked example.

Pre Calman. Economy 100 units. Scottish tax 10%, UK tax 10%. Both Governments get 10 units of tax.


Post Calman. Economy boosted to 110 units by tax change by Scots Government, Scottish tax 8%, UK 10%. So Scotland gets 8.8 units and UK gets 11units.


Fiscal drag. The total amount of tax over time tends to come increasingly from higher rate tax payers. So initially Scotland would get 50% from basic, 25% from higher (40%) tax payers and 20% from super tax payers (new 50% rate). Now over time tax payers move upscale. So as we move upscale Scotland gets a smaller percentage of the total Income Tax take. Also Cuthberts caution that any change in higher rates could adversely affect Scotland.


The Cuthberts propose that the best solution would be to follow the Canadian system where the Provinces get a fixed percentage of total provincial tax take. Calman looked closely at the Canadian scheme but adopted his own mechanism.

Further to the Cuthbert critique, I would add my own concerns. The tax system must be kept consistent to avoid evasion and distortions. The two that concern me are Capital Gains Tax and Small Company Corporation Tax. Scotland would only get power to set Income tax.


At present these tax rates are as follows:


Income tax 20% std rate

Capital Gains 18%

Small company Corporation Tax 21%.

Clearly all these rates are similar!


Now lets imagine that Scotland decided to increase Income Tax to 25% (10% UK +15% Scots). I’m a self employed plumber. I incorporate my business and pay 21% company tax to avoid higher personal tax. Business owners with assets could take Capital gains at 18% rather than paying higher personal taxes of 25%. So I would argue that all these taxes are interlinked and Scotland altering Income Tax but not the others would be unworkable and lead to avoidance and distortion. This leads me to think that either Calman has not through this issue or he does not expect any Government to use these tax varying powers.


A further thought occurred to me this morning. With Cuthberts first point, if we stimulate Scots Economy by cutting IT, we could also see a growth in Corporation Tax, VAT, Stamp duty, National Insurance and so on. Who benefits? The UK Exchequor yet the Scots Government could lose out by getting less from its cut of Income Tax.
My thinking is that Calman has produced something that is 'reasonably' easy to understand and sounds plausible but in reality will not be used. A bit like the existing +/- 3% measure. Unless we do a thorough professional job or move to full fiscal independence, we're just fiddling at the edges.
Of course I'm not an economist!

Saturday, 28 November 2009

New Powers for Scotland - Where's the Catch?



I purposely haven't posted on Jim Murphy's announcement, made earlier this week, of 'new powers' for Scotland, because I saw no need. It was a move to achieve headlines, nothing more and nothing less. It is not going to happen because labour will not win the election and the Scots won't be so blatantly bribed.

'Scotland will be given greater tax-raising powers under the biggest shake-up in the nation's finances for 30 years' reported Reuters and the MSM splurged similar headlines over their front pages. Sounds too good to be true that Jim Murphy would agree to implement the recommendations of the Calman Commission doesn't it? Of course it is.

Firstly there is consensus in the Scottish Parliament that Scotland should have control over its speed limits, drink driving laws and air gun law, but Westminster refuse to hand over any powers until after the general election. The Scottish government has made it clear that it is ready to legislate where agreement exists and has now laid out a timetable but it is the UK government which is stalling the process.

Commenting on the UK government's proposals to transfer certain tax raising and borrowing power, Pete Wishart MP stated: "The Calman Commission's own experts have described these flawed tax proposals as 'worse than undesirable, they are unworkable'.

"The SNP government is seeking full fiscal autonomy and with that full responsibility for Scotland's finances. Anything less risks being a messy fudge which will damage the Scottish economy in the long term."

The catch? None of the terms of the announcement will be implemented until after the general election. What if labour lose the general election? There's the catch. In that case will the Tories implement the Calman recommendations? No. David Cameron has already stated he would not consider constitutional change in the next parliament and that would mean until 2015 at the earliest.

Scotland doesn't need flawed tax raising powers which will tie it to England even more. We need full fiscal control. What other country is unable to raise and spend its own taxes and have full fiscal control?

Monday, 14 September 2009

Sharing Income Tax



The title doesn't mean income tax will be shared more equally in this country, but it means your income tax details may be shared with other countries who have signed up to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The United Kingdom signed this agreement in 1961.

A meeting was held in Mexico City last week under the auspices of the Paris-based OECD, whose implicit goal is to create a global high-tax cartel.

In order to create a global tax cartel, the OECD needs to have tax information shared among nations - which means that the citizen of any country that signs on to this scheme may have his or her tax information shared with other member jurisdictions. It has managed to get 87 jurisdictions to sign on to its global 'tax standard'. The high-tax countries (of which we are certainly one), are using the OECD to threaten low-tax jurisdictions to sign this agreement.

It's worth mentioning that the tax bullies at the OECD and at other international organisation, such as the United Nations, International Monetary Fund and World Bank, who demand that others pay higher taxes, enjoy tax-free personal income courtesy of the world's taxpayers.

The good news is that some low-tax jurisdictions are beginning to fight back. Late last month, the oldest bank in Switzerland, Wegelin & Co., issued a remarkable investment commentary entitled 'Farewell America'. It's well worth a read.

Wegelin has decided to no longer invest in the US because the new IRS regulations, which foreign banks must follow, are so vague, onerous and incomprehensible that it could never be sure the bank was not at risk.

So remember, when you complete your tax return, the details could be sent all round the world for governments to peruse. All done without your authority or knowledge of course.


Speaking of tax Spy Blog has an interesting story concerning security at HMRC.

Related Posts with Thumbnails