Showing posts with label Jackson Carlaw. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jackson Carlaw. Show all posts
Tuesday, 27 September 2011
Is Murdo Quietly Confident?
I jumped the gun publishing this poll because on deadline day, last Friday, the list MSP Margaret Mitchell entered the fray. Would her candidacy have made any difference to the poll results? No.
Murdo Fraser, my Tory spies tell me, is doing a sterling job on the campaign trail assuring the grassroots fully understand his plan to abolish the party and establish a new one completely independent of Westminster control. His support for a move toward full fiscal autonomy is being less well received as many traditionalists view any further transfer of power from London to Edinburgh as a betrayal of the Union.
Ruth Davidson's political immaturity has been highlighted by her staffing problems and she, like Jackson Carlaw and Margaret Mitchell, is yet to produce any substantive proposals for the desperately needed overhaul of the party's internal structures. With the exception of Murdo Fraser, all the candidates are far to the right of the Scottish mainstream on the issue of constitutional reform.
The campaign is still young and there is time for someone to see the light and join Murdo in his effort to survive on the political scene in Scotland, yet why do I feel nobody cares?
Rebranding, regrouping, reinventing - call it what you will the Tories, along with the Libdems, will be a fringe party in Scotland for many years to come. The result of the leadership contest in November isn't going to set the heather on fire.
Tuesday, 6 September 2011
Who Will Win The Poisoned Chalice?
While Alex Salmond basks in the glow of ex-Labour MSP Andy Kerr's compliments, I wonder if he will spare a thought for Tory MSP Murdo Fraser.
Murdo, the deputy leader of Scotland's tories, got his leadership campaign underway yesterday with his bid to dissolve the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party (SCUP) and create a new party built on "new unionism". About 80 Tories attended the launch but the party's biggest single backer in Scotland, Sir Jack Harvie the transport tycoon, wasn't impressed in the slightest and has thrown his weight behind newly elected MSP Ruth Davidson. Although Murdo is currently in the lead the odds have reduced today.
I think he's on the right track if the words Scottish Conservatives are not to be buried without ceremony but, try as I may I can't find anything of substance in Murdo's proposals other than a name change and that's a shame because I thought he had his finger on the pulse of disillusioned members.
The other contender, Jackson Carlaw, considers the proposal is 'dividing the party rather than uniting it.' What he doesn't realise is that the party has been divided for years and requires a complete restructure. Of course such rebuilds take time and it may be some years before former Tory voters, who now vote SNP, trust their natural party enough to support it.
If a complete restructure is rejected by the Tories then they will die a slow death here. If a rebuild is approved it will be some years before the Tories just may be able to become a major player.
Who will win the poisoned chalice?
Labels:
Jackson Carlaw,
Murdo Fraser,
Ruth Davidson,
Scottish tories
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

